Giant Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich | Big Frozen Chocolate Treat

Looking for a chilling and thrilling dessert that’s out of the ordinary? This Giant Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich is just what you need to bring your next party or celebration from great to perfect! It features delicious ice cream in-between two luscious brownies for a taste so good that it could be the very reason to have the party!

Giant Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe

Ingredients you will need:

  • 2 (8-inch) square baking pans
  • Aluminum foil
  • Basking sheet or freezer-proof serving platter
  • 1 (19 to 22 oz.) pkg. brownie mix
  • Eggs, oil, and water as directed on package
  • 1 C. chopped Milky Way candy bars
  • 1 qt. vanilla ice cream
  • 1 1/2 C. whipped topping
  • 1 C. candy coated chocolate candies (M&M’s)

Line two 8-inch square baking pans (Rada Cutlery Stoneware used below) with aluminium foil, shiny side up. Lightly coat with cooking spray.

Preparing foil and Milky Ways

Chop 3 frozen Milky Way bars. This should make approximately 1 cup of Milky Way pieces.

Chopping Milky Ways

Prepare brownie mix according to directions on package. This should include eggs, oil, and water, as well as the mix itself. Once brownie mix has been stirred, add Milky Way pieces to mixture. Stir.

Stirring Brownie Mixture

Distribute mixture evenly across prepared 8-inch pans. Be sure to push batter into corners. Place in oven preheated to 350 degrees for 25 minutes.

Pouring brownie mixture into pan

Once brownies bake, allow to cool, then place in freezer for 1 hour. Remove from freezer and then remove aluminum foil.

Preparing Giant Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich

Remove 1 quart vanilla ice cream from freezer (if you like, you could soften the ice cream beforehand in a refrigerator). Completely remove ice cream from box and cut ice cream into several blocks that will cover an entire block of brownie. The Rada Ham Slicer is perfect for this. Once brownie block is covered, place the other brownie block on top of the ice cream. Smooth out edges of ice cream as necessary.

Cutting block of vanilla ice cream

Cover top brownie block with whipped topping. We choose to cover the edges and place a dollop of topping in the middle, but you can do as you prefer.

Whipped topping being poured on Giant Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich

Place M&M’s on whipped topping.

Giant Ice Cream Sandwich with M&Ms

Serve and enjoy! If preferred, you can make this without the Milky Way bars, or use another candy altogether!

Completed Giant Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich

Not Just For Ham!

Rada Ham Slicer

The Rada Ham Slicer is a versatile tool that you’ll use for more than just cutting ham. Its 9 ½-inch blade is the longest we produce at Rada, meaning this is ideal for slicing through bigger foods. You’ll find yourself using it on cakes, jerky meat, melons, prime rib, or even for cutting a block of ice cream for the above recipe. It’s made in the USA, and comes with a Lifetime Guarantee!

Visit our online Rada Kitchen Store to have the Rada Ham Slicer brought to your home!

Follow Rada Online!

image of the Rada Cutlery logo

Thanks for visiting our blog! Be sure to visit us on your favorite social media platform for the latest recipes, news, and promotions offered by Rada Cutlery!

Dessert Heaven!

Our Giant Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich isn’t the only great dessert recipe we feature. Check out these recipes for more sweet ways to thrill your guests!

Candy Bar Pizza

candy bar pizza

This wildly fun and inventive dessert turns a giant cookie and your favorite candies and makes them into a delicious spin on a pizza!

Better Than Anything Cake

Better Than Anything Cake

The title says it all! This chocolate cake will blow your mind and leave you begging for more!

The Best Fundraising Idea for Kids!

image of the Rada Cutlery logo

Do you have or know of a child in need of a great fundraiser? If so, Rada Cutlery is the answer! Rada partners with tens of thousands of nonprofit groups each year to raise money for noble causes. Those who fundraise with Rada can do so through catalog, event, or online sales, with each item sold earning an amazing 40% profit!

Check out our fundraising catalog to learn more about Rada fundraising!


Check out the Rada Cutlery EASY guide to learn more about why a Rada fundraiser is your group’s best fundraising option!

Rada's fundraising EASY guide.

Giant Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich Video Recipe



Pin it to Pinterest!

Giant Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe

Start Video Transcript

Hi, Kristy in the Rada Kitchen, and today I want to show you how to make a giant ice cream sandwich. It would be a perfect cake for a birthday party, and it just takes prepared brownie mix, and I want to show you how to prepare the pans.

So you’ll need 2 8 x 8 inch pans. I’m going to use the Rada Stoneware. But we’re going to take that brownie out so we’re going to line it with tinfoil. So you just cut a piece of tinfoil to the size of the pan. You just push it around the edges, so it’s pretty smooth. I am doing the shiny side up. The shiny side reflects the heat, so if you put in on the bottom it’s going to force the heat away, so you want to make sure the heat comes into your brownie mix. Now just coat that with cooking spray. So you can set those aside.

Then I have family size fudge brownie mix. Just bought it at the store in the box. To that I’m going to add three Milky Way candy bars, or about a cup of candy pieces. We’re just going to chop those up. I put these in the freezer, so they’re easier to chop, and this Rada French Chef’s knife chops right through those. This is going to add a caramel taste to these brownies.

Now this is just a box of brownie mix. You need a 19-22 oz. size. You’re just going to compare it to the instructions on the box. Then add a fourth cup of water, two eggs, half cup oil, and then just stir for 50 strokes.

So once we’ve stirred our brownie mix, we’re going to add our chopped Milky Way candy bars. You’ll want to have your oven preheated to 350 degrees. And now, we’re going to evenly pour that batter into our prepared 8 x 8 inch pans. Make sure you push it into the corners. Then we’re going to put this in that 350 degree oven for about 25 minutes.

So our brownies got baked. I let them cool and had them in the freezer for an hour. And now, I’m going to put that on a serving plate. That’s why you want to grease your tinfoil really well, so it doesn’t stick to that. Here I have a quart of vanilla ice cream. It’s best if you get it in a box like this. I softened it a little bit in the refrigerator. I’m just going to take it out of that container and take this ham knife and make slices of ice cream and lay that on top of that brownie. We can level off the edges.

And now we’ll take our other brownie and place it on the ice cream. You can level off the sides with a knife. Then you’ll want to put this back in the freezer until it’s ready to serve. I like to take a little whipped topping and spread it over it. If you do put it in the freezer, you’ll want to get it out 15 minutes before you serve it, so the ice cream has time to soften. And that’s the giant ice cream sandwich cake. Enjoy!

End of Video Transcript

recipe image
Recipe Name
Ice Cream Sandwich Brownie
Published On
Preparation Time
Cook Time
Total Time

Did You Know?
Rada Cutlery offers unique fundraising opportunities. Learn more

I’m looking to buy
kitchen products for
myself or as gifts.

I need to raise money
for my group, club,
school, or church.

I want to earn a profit
for myself, selling
products I believe in.

Discover sources
in your area that sell
Rada products.