Grilled Cream Cheese Recipe | Unique Grilled Cheese Sandwich

You’ll forget about all other grilled cheese sandwiches once you’ve tasted this amazing Ultimate Grilled Cheese! Easy to make and stunningly delicious, this will instantly become your go-to grilled cheese!

Ultimate Grilled Cheese Sandwich Recipe

Ingredients you will need:

  • 1-3 oz. pkg. cream cheese
  • 1/2 C. mayonnaise
  • 1 C. shredded cheddar cheese
  • 1 C. shredded mozzarella cheese
  • 1/2 tsp. garlic powder
  • 1/4 tsp. seasoning salt
  • 10 slices Italian bread
  • 2 T. butter

Ready 10 slices Italian bread. We sliced our own out of a loaf.

Kristy slices fresh Italian bread.

In a mixing bowl, place 3 oz. cream cheese.

Kristy adds cream cheese to bowl.

Add 1/2 cup mayonnaise.

Kristy adds mayonnaise.

Add 1 cup shredded cheddar cheese.

Kristy adds shredded cheddar cheese.

Add 1 cup shredded mozzarella cheese.

Kristy adds shredded mozzarella cheese.

Add 1/2 tsp. garlic powder and 1/4 tsp. seasoning salt. Stir thoroughly until blended.

Kristy adds seasoning.

Spread mixture across 5 slices Italian bread.

Kristy spreads cheese mixture on Italian bread slices.

Once mixture is spread, add another slice to each existing piece.

Kristy places bread on cheese.

On a skillet set to medium or medium-high, melt 2 tablespoons butter.

Kristy melts butter on skillet.

Place sandwiches on skillet and cook.

Kristy cooks sandwiches on skillet.

Cook until they start to brown. Once they start browning, they will harden quickly, so pay close attention.

Kristy prepares to remove sandwiches from heat.

Once sandwiches are browned, remove from heat. Cut in half or other desired portion.

Kristy slices sandwiches.

Serve and enjoy!

Kristy poses with completed Ultimate Grilled Cheese and 101 Recipes with Cream Cheese cookbook.

The Best Bread Knife!

Rada Large Bread Knife Features

The Rada 10″ Bread Knife is your ticket to perfect slices of bread! Featuring a handy serrated blade, it easily cuts through all types of bread, making it a must-have for those who love bread (and who doesn’t?). The 10″ Bread Knife is protected by a Lifetime Guarantee, and, like all Rada products, is made in the USA!

The Rada 10″ Bread Knife can be ordered at our online Rada Kitchen Store!

A Great Cream Cheese Recipe Book!

101 Recipes with Cream Cheese cookbook

The 101 Recipes with Cream Cheese cookbook is loaded with recipes that will blow your mind! From appetizers to desserts, you’ll love every bite of these fantastic dishes. From potato salad to bacon-wrapped chicken, there’s something in here for everyone. Just be sure to keep your refrigerator stocked with cream cheese, because you’re going to need it!

The 101 Recipes with Cream Cheese cookbook is available at the online Rada Kitchen Store!

The Ultimate Sunday Dinner Gift!

The amazing Rada Sunday Dinner Gift Set features a bread knife and a ham slicer!

Set the table and get ready for a delicious feast prepared with the Rada Sunday Dinner Gift Set! This collection features Rada’s Ham Slicer and 10″ Bread Knife. Both made from surgical-quality stainless steel and are backed by a Lifetime Guarantee!

The online Rada Kitchen Store has the Sunday Dinner Gift Set available for purchase!

A Smart Fundraising Idea!

image of the Rada Cutlery logo

You won’t find a better way to fundraise than Rada Cutlery. Since 1948, we’ve helped tens of thousands of nonprofit groups meet their financial goals each year. Your group is guaranteed an amazing 40% profit on each and every sale, making sure that all efforts go extra far. Churches, schools, sports teams, clubs, civic organizations, and many more partner with Rada Cutlery to get where they need to be.

Visit our website to get started with a successful Rada Cutlery fundraiser!

Ultimate Grilled Cheese Sandwich Video Recipe


Pin the Ultimate Grilled Cheese Sandwich Collage!

A few steps from the process of making this treat!

Share this with your friends on Pinterest!

Ultimate Grilled Cheese Video Transcript

Hi, it’s Kristy in the Rada kitchen. Today I’m going to make the Ultimate Grilled Cheese Sandwich. It’s 3 different types of cheese. I’m getting this out of our cream cheese cookbook, so, as you can guess, one of the ingredients is cream cheese. It’s super easy to make but super delicious, so let’s get started.

So you need about 10 slices of an Italian bread. You can buy it sliced, I just like to buy it in a loaf and slice. This Rada Serrated Bread Knife makes it really easy to slice this bread. Some people don’t like as much bread, so it will easily cut thin slices or thick slices. This nice sharp knife prevents you from smashing down. You get a nice, rounded bread slice with the knife’s serrated teeth.

Now, I’m going to set this down so I can show you how to mix up the cheese filling. In a bowl, you’re going to take a 3 ounce package of cream cheese, half a cup of mayonnaise, a cup of shredded cheddar cheese, a cup of shredded mozzarella, and a half a teaspoon of garlic powder and about ¼ teaspoon season salt. This is new to Rada Cutlery. We have a burger and fries seasoning, we have a barbecue seasoning, we have some marinades that are really tasty and good.

We’re just going to mix this together. It’s going to get kind of pasty, which is good. I guarantee you not to be turned off by the mayonnaise, because that’s what holds it together and gives it a rich flavor. That cream cheese and mozzarella and cheddar are all going to melt together.

So, on 5 slices we’re going to spread this mixture. It’s really easy to spread with this Party Spreader. It spreads butter and jam. It’s great to set out on your appetizer table for cheeseballs. I like to put the slices out so we know that they can evenly share the cheese.

Now I’m going to go in and top these with our remaining slices. And we’re going to go over to our skillet and fry them up. We’re going to take about 2 tablespoons of butter and put that on this skillet. We’ll add our sandwiches. We’re just going to make a couple for now. I like to cook them on medium or medium-high, but you have to watch them, because once they start to brown they’ll go fast.

Once your sandwiches are brown on both sides they’re ready to serve. The cheese is all melty and they’re ready to serve. This is our shorter bread slicer, for muffins and smaller breads like this. And that’s the Ultimate Grilled Cheese Sandwich, one of the recipes in our 101 Recipes with Cream Cheese cookbook. Enjoy!

End of Video Transcript

recipe image
Recipe Name
Ultimate Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Published On
Preparation Time
Cook Time
Total Time
Average Rating
51star1star1star1star1star Based on 1 Review(s)

Did You Know?
Rada Cutlery offers unique fundraising opportunities. Learn more

I’m looking to buy
kitchen products for
myself or as gifts.

I need to raise money
for my group, club,
school, or church.

I want to earn a profit
for myself, selling
products I believe in.

Discover sources
in your area that sell
Rada products.